Abercrombie & Fitch to pull line of T-shirts

Abercrombie & Fitch to pull line of T-shirts Saturday, November 05, 2005
By Monica Haynes and Moustafa Ayad, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

Retail giant Abercrombie & Fitch, bowing to increasing national pressure started by a local girls group, has agreed to stop selling several controversial T-shirts.

Splendid singing, music and message -- with a recent victory!

The hardest element of this posting is trying to figure out who should get top billing. All were excellent.

Emma Blackman-Mathis join with Emma's Revolution to bask in the glory of the recent victory.
Pgh's Emma and DC-based Emma's Revolution hooked up in Friendship. Check out the t-shirts. (Click image for larger view.)

Girlcott co-organizer, Emma, (16-year old from Pittsburgh) back from major network appearances, and triumph with A&F's decision to yank the t-shirt line. (keep reading)

Musical power.

In May 2002, the song, (my favorite) "Swimming to the Other Side" was featured on NPR's All Things Considered. In the interview, Pete Seeger said, "The powers that be can control the media (but) it's hard to stop a good song . . . Pat's songs will be sung well into the 22nd century." The tremendous and unprecedented response by NPR listeners made Emma's Revolution CD, "Hands," the #1 seller on Amazon.com for three days following.

Pat Humphries and Sandy Opatow, (neither named Emma -- but both want to dance at the revolution) were in the process of moving to the Washington DC area from New York City on September 11, 2001. Since then, they have been performing at concerts, teach-ins and rallies. At one event as Gulf War II began, the singers/songwriters lead 10,000 people in an outdoor concert in NYC in the singing of their song "Peace, Salaam, Shalom." That inspiring event, less than a month after September 11th, was requested and repeated at an all-night peace vigil in NYC on the first 9-11 anniversary.

"Democracy Now!" with Amy Goodman plays a number of their songs. Rhythms Magazine called the "Hands" CD a "powerful and energetic album. . . one of the best of 2001." Sheet music in PDF format of the peace song is online.

Anne Feeney stages another great event.

Back to the t-shirt story:

On November 2, 2005, the news was about free PR for A&F and the girls. Since then, the A&F changed its tune. The t-shirts are gone.

Newsday.com: Student 'girlcott' protests Abercrombie t-shirts

With a few words on their T-shirts, Abercrombie & Fitch lets young women send a message: 'Who needs a brain when you have these?'

A group of female high school students have a message for A&F: Stop degrading us.

The Allegheny County (Pa.) Girls have started a boycott -- or girlcott, as they're calling it -- of the retailer. The campaign, conceived three weeks ago during the group's monthly meeting, went national on NBC's "Today" show. (Emma was on all the major networks: CNN, Fox, etc.)

"We're telling [girls] to think about the fact that they're being degraded," Emma Blackman-Mathis, the 16-year-old co-chair of the group. "We're all going to come together in this one effort to fight this message that we're getting from pop culture."

Abercrombie has been a lightning rod for criticism:

In 2003, a catalog containing photos of topless women and bare-bottomed men provoked so much outrage that the company pulled the publication.

Last year, after the U.S. Olympic gymnastics team failed to win a gold medal, the company sold T-shirts with the phrase "L is for loser" next to a picture of a gymnast on the rings. Those shirts were pulled from the racks after USA Gymastics called for a boycott.

While Abercrombie backed down in those cases, it show no signs of doing so this time. (Ha! A&F did back down this time. The young women from Allegheny County won.)

"Our clothing appeals to a wide variety of customers. These particular T-shirts have been very popular among adult women to whom they are marketed," a company spokesman said in a statement.

News of the girlcott hadn't reached Tawana Clark, 20, who was applying for a job at the Abercrombie & Fitch store in Water Tower Place on Tuesday. But she doesn't think the protest will work.

"I think it's only older people that have a problem with it," she said. "Teenagers don't have a problem with it." (Ha, ha, ha!)

Clark sees the shirts as funny, not offensive. "It's not to be taken seriously," she said. (Say what?)

The aim of the girlcott is to convince people that the T-shirts are offensive, but young people don't care if they are, according to David Krafft, senior vice president of Chicago-based Graziano, Krafft and Zale Advertising.

"You figure they're appealing to a younger audience demographic and (young people) are going to want go for brands that are more cutting edge, or viewed as more cutting edge," Krafft said. "So it's just going to be a benefit anyway to Abercrombie & Fitch."

The attention from this boycott is likely to help Abercrombie's image, and its audience will be attracted to the controversy, said Steve Bassill, president of Libertyville-based QDI strategies, a marketing consulting firm. (WRONG!)

"That's been their whole strategy, isn't it, to be radical?" Bassill asked. "I think that's what we've seen for quite a while from them."

Krafft says the "Today" show appearance was tantamount to free advertising.

According to Chicago-based media company Starcom USA, a 30-second commercial on "Today" costs approximately $58,000.

The girlcott girls were on for several minutes. The girlcott almost is "playing into their hands," Bassill said.

Heather Arnett, adviser for the girls' group, said it doesn't matter if Abercrombie gets free advertising. They're already a giant as far as she's concerned. What matters is empowering young women, she said, who in turn serve as examples to other young women.
"A week ago, Katie Couric knew who Abercrombie & Fitch was, but she didn't know who Emma Blackman-Mathis was," Arnett said. "A bunch of teenage girls are being interviewed by national media about what they think. And that is the news."

Blackman-Mathis admits that, at first glance, the T-shirts are a little funny.

But the more she looked at them, the less amusing they were. She's still stunned to have appeared on national TV and is hopeful the message will reach young girls.

"Worst-case scenario, I just want girls to at least think about everything that they buy," Blackman-Mathis said. "Think about the message that it conveys to themselves and other people when they wear it."

Her best-case scenario?

"They would stand up and say something for themselves and for girls."

Fantastic prime-time political TV -- West Wing's debate

Tonights TV show, West Wing, delivered a wonderful bit of drama. Plus, I think the presentation by the fictional characters made a top-shelf contrast between two points of view.

It was so good, I don't even miss the lack of a WQED debate on the mayor's race. Talk about contrasts.

Bob O'Connor now has a fresh excuse for not going onto any TV debate stage. Bob would look like hell next to the prime time actors in West Wing.

The Pitt News covers O'Connor's promises -- before they are broken

Among other things, we read:

The Pitt News - O'Connor promises revitalization

O’Connor never went to college.

But, O'Connor worked in a restaurant in the Cathedral of Learning. (Roy Rodgers)

O’Connor got involved in Greek Week, a big thing.

O'Connor got involved with the hospitals. (Assume he sold fries to them too.)

O'Connor grew up not knowing anything about politics.

O'Connor wants to retain more of the city’s large collegiate population. O'Connor says, "Job opportunities are certainly here." (Yeah, right.)

O'Connor thinks the key is to create the atmosphere [college students] feel comfortable in and can enjoy. (More enjoyable fast food?)

O'Connor thinks Oakland should be able to hold graduates to Pittsburgh. (Everyone wants to settle down and raise a faimly in Oakland, right?)

A major theme of O’Connor’s is expanding transportation. Bob didn't learn his first lesson from his spring campaign in 2005. Bob's first step then dealt with the creation of a streetcar from Oakland to Downtown. His plan went over like a lead baloon. Bob back-peddaled around those streetcar statements throughout the spring. Now O'Connor falls back into the same rut.

O’Connor believes another key is attractive neighborhoods for young people and old people who don't live here.

O'Connor thinks young people want to live in Squirrel Hill because of Barnes & Noble.

O'Connor does not think Downtown Pittsburgh is linked with Oakland.

O'Connor thinks job centers, Downtown and Oakland, need to be linked. Bob does not understand that a hospital employee does not need to go down to Grant Street often. These centers are centers unto themselves. The link that really needs to occur is between residents and work places. People live at home and go to work. People at one job don't need to travel to other jobs site centers as a normal course of travel.

O'Connor thinks Pittsburgh is growing everywhere except Downtown.

O’Connor thinks Downtown housing would jumpstart revitalization. Frankly, I think it is silly to subsidize housing for rich people. And, the shift to move Downtown into a housing center subtracts from Downtown's strength as a job center.

“The only thing that will change Downtown is having people live here. That’s what changed Squirrel Hill, all the shops and cafes,” he said. “Same thing can be done with Downtown and Oakland, they could do a lot better.”

Humm. O'Connor forgets to mention that loss of the local shops in Squirrel Hill because of the Waterfront in Homestead. Lots of small businesses went out of business because of the subsidized outdoor mall in Homestead. And, given O'Connor's thinking, why is Homestead not booming with housing because of all the shops and stores there?

O’Connor wants to work with companies that are already in Pittsburgh to help them expand and grow. But, that didn't happen with Homestead's Waterfront and existing businesses in Squirrel Hill while Bob was on City Council.

O'Connor thinks there have been plenty of debates. In the primary we had around 80 or 90. O'Connor can't count. But more over, O'Connor must think that freshmen who do lots of homework can stand up to their next professor in the next semester and say, "I've done plenty of homework -- last semester." Even a second grader knows that first-grade homework doesn't count in the next, present round.

Comprehensive article on Pgh Mayor Race from State College

AP Wire Former city councilman, attorney vie to be Pittsburgh mayor The run-up to next week's mayoral election had all the makings of a hot contest: a struggling city whose finances are in tatters, a three-term mayor choosing not to run again, and a former City Council president going head-to-head with a political newcomer.

E-Democracy Workshop with Peter Shane - now at OSU and CMU (prior)

E-Democracy Workshop The Center for Interdisciplinary Law and Policy Studies (CILPS), along with the Department of Journalism and Communication, the Department of City and Regional Planning, and the Ohio Supercomputer Center, invite you to join us November 17-18 for a hands-on workshop to introduce government personnel and other interested citizens to the emerging world of web applications to foster citizen input into public policy making.

Others think otherwise on No for Newman

My recent email blast generated some welcomed feedback, as expected. Some good and some bad -- but all of it welcomed. The most interesting exchange, so far, came from Rob Keenan III, (C. Robert) who is with email as crkeenan -at- dmcpc -dot- com.

Dear Mark,

I don't believe we have met, although I have been entertained by your libertarian e-mails for awhile now. Allow me to introduce myself.

I'm a lawyer who's been practicing for over 26 years. In addition to the usual legal practice, I have also represented law-abiding gun owners against the gun grabbers. I also represented pro-lifers (successfully) in 1994 when powerful special interests attempted to purge them from the primary election ballot. Before I was a lawyer, I was a county chairman for Ronald Reagan in 1976.

My conservative credentials run wide and deep. So I was more than a little concerned about the distortions and conclusions in your e-mail regarding the retention election this November 8 for a friend of freedom in Pennsylvania, Justice Sandra Schultz Newman.

Distortions? You allude to the current Pennsylvania Supreme Court having ruled on the July midnight surprise (the pay raise and the unvouchered expenses). They have not.

Then you made sweeping recommendations about the retention election next week. Please let me address the question of Justice Newman's record. Perhaps you will see why we need to retain her.

Justice Newman was one of two Justices last year to hold that "no registry" in the Uniform Firearms Act means just that - "no registry". She rejected the Big Government stretches of the Governor's office and the mainstream media.

In 2001, Justice Newman voted in favor of free speech and against prior restraints on political ads, an area of intense concern for pro-gun, pro-life, and conservative activists. I know - I helped litigate that case.

But that's not the point. The point is what was discovered more than twenty years ago when a clueless "New York Times" reporter was covering a Senate race in Idaho. At a rally, speaker after speaker tipped the hat to "the three boxes of our liberty." Finally, the reporter asked someone in the crowd, "What are these three boxes I keep hearing about?"

The man looked at the reporter with surprise and said, "The ballot box, the jury box, and the cartridge box."

So I'll vote "Yes" to retain Justice Sandra Schultz Newman on the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. When liberty's in the dock, she's one of the judges I'd want hearing the case.

Sincerely,
Rob Keenan

---

I wrote to the sender with thanks for the feedback and asked, "Can I publish this on my blog? Do you want your name used? Do you want your email used? Do you want to have me scrub it to take out the personal stuff?

His reply:

Sure.
It's OK to use my name & e-mail. Thanks for asking. And thanks for keeping liberty issues before us here in Western Pennsylvania.
Yours,
Rob

The race in August 2006

Talk about an early bird getting the worm.... Here is your advance warning. But, I'm only going to sign up in July.

Pittsburgh Triathlon & Adventure RaceNinth Annual Pittsburgh Triathlon & Adventure Race, Sunday, August 6, 2006, Olympic Distance Triathlon and Sprint Distance Adventure Race at the North Shore Riverfront

Analysis: Political landscape is changed -- like the book, The Tipping Point

I was very sad when O'Toole took a bit of a vacation for some time off while I was running for the PA Senate in the special election in the spring of 2005. O'Toole is a good reporter. He is now joined by J.P., another top reporter at the P-G. I hope one of the two get to cover the race we're gearing for in the months to come.

Analysis: Political landscape is changed By James O'Toole, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

Valid points:

... the tactical keys were the newer media that emerged...

... With the Internet blogs and talk radio, no matter what happened you had people paying attention, ...

... The biggest losers were single issue candidates who wanted to run against incumbents based solely on this issue.... Right. Just a footnote, I'm not a "single issue candidate." I've got a platform that spans 100+ pages. My knock is I've got more than a handful of topics where I can put forth significant, simple solutions.

.... senior GOP Senate aide, acknowledged the raw nerves, but professed confidence that they would be soothed over time. Think again. The soothing may happen over time. But, time does not heal, just in itself. Pennsylvania needs to fix many of its policies. Our state needs to change in some fundamental ways as to how it operates and the cronies acts that have been tolerated. Then, the healing can begin and the people can rest. We need to put more faith into the consitution, into freedoms and into truthful reforms that allow all to make choices for themselves and have the educational opportunities to grow. Going back to the status quo isn't going to put people back into their slumber.

Home Page to a new candidate site

Good luck.

Home Page People power democracy. I am running for Congress because I believe I will better represent the people of Pittsburgh and the 14th District. No speech writers, no professional campaign people, no corporate PACs, just the people powering democracy.

Slots panel's wish list is vague

Slots panel's wish list is vague Mayor's task force gives casino hopefuls no specific demands

Of course. The appointed pannel has the 'authority mindset.' They have no mandate. They have no standing. They have been pulled to a dance with a date with a nice body and little else.

Interaction is not this administration's stength. Weakness rules. So too are the outcomes.

The fire, passion and conviction that resides in the citizens has been snuffed in the past. Most of it has departed this town as well. Those with real interests elsewhere are not willing to devote more time to hitting one's heads against a wall of do-nothingness that is now rooted in Grant Street.

There are three reasons why I won't get what I want out of this gambling saga. One of those reasons is the lack of "will." There isn't a political will for insuring that the best process and best outcome happens.

Do NOT subsidize housing for rich people -- anywhere. No TIFs either, give their saga.

PIIN should be on this. Progressives should be on this. Pittsburgh Laurels & Lances - PittsburghLIVE.com Lance: To PNC Financial Services Group. This very wealthy banking giant is looking for $48 million in public money to make its proposed $170 million Downtown office, retail and residential complex a reality. Normally, we'd call this an obscenity. Because it's a bank trying it, we'll call it what it is -- pornography. Taxpayers are not venture capitalists. Given the history of public subsidies and failures in the Golden Triangle, PNC should be ashamed of itself. As should the city's Urban Redevelopment Authority and Gov. Ed Rendell for entertaining this latest attempt at a public molestation.

Pittsburgh Laurels & Lances, The FIX flap with Mayor, but where was he 1, 2, and 3 years ago, yet alone 12?

To forgive and forget is fine, but I'm not yet able to let a top official off the hook, yet. Where was Murphy years ago as gambling-interests rolled into town and jacked up river-front property values? That land-speculation along with the city's heavy handed pipe-dreams with stadiums and Fifth & Forbes, plus undue taxes in parking (50%), etc., have squashed the hopes of a sensible marketpace.

The marketplace rebounds, but the marketplace has been beaten repeatedly.

Every system, institution and family in the city is much more frail today because of the lack of dynamic leadership and bad policies on Grant Street.

The "real fix" that has "been in" has been the "decay fix" of the marketplace from public officials who are so self absorbed that they believe they have the sway to fix markets.

The 'fix is in' line of Murphy's wasn't the whopper of that day. The Mayor said, "Evan is right." The past leader of the anti-gambling group, No Dice, knows of the ills to our society and culture and has spoken about about them for years. Now, Mayor Murphy agrees with Evan and gives him direct credit. Evan's reply was, "Where were you, (Mayor Murphy) five years ago?"

nd Pittsburgh Laurels & Lances - PittsburghLIVE.com It's about time: On Oct. 27, Pittsburgh Mayor Tom Murphy claimed 'the fix' was in regarding the city's lone slots casino license. He offered no evidence; he blamed the media for not doing their job. On Wednesday, a full week later, Mr. Murphy, pummeled in the media and by the state Gaming Control Board, retracted his allegation. Which only affirms the recklessness of the mayor's behavior. January can't come soon enough.

Vietnam Study, Casting Doubts, Remains Secret - New York Times

Vietnam Study, Casting Doubts, Remains Secret - New York Times N.S.A. officers deliberately distorted critical intelligence to cover up their mistakes, ...

World Peace -- coming to a mogul near you soon.

Olympic flag, white for peace.
SI.com - 2006 Winter Olympics - UN proclaims Olympic truce for Turin Winter Games

The U.N. General Assembly adopted by acclamation on Thursday a resolution encouraging all nations to observe an Olympic truce during the 2006 Winter Games to be held in Turin, Italy, in February.

Weinroth sent a spokesperson to PIIN, thankfully

Bob O'Connor was absent from the PIIN meeting. Fine. But Bob, you could have sent a representative.

A standing-room-only crowd gathered at a church in Manchester on the North Side. The meeting was organized by the Pittsburgh Interfaith Impact Network.

Joe Weinroth was represented by Markie Bilkie, Republican.

American teens devour and feed Web's content

This is why we need a YOUTH Tech Summit to occur in Pittsburgh and be the largest annual event in the Convention Center.

American teens devour and feed Web's content American teenagers are doing more than just passively surfing the Web: More than half are adding their own content to the Internet, through blogs and other interactive means, according to a new survey.

Double posting?

I seem to have double-sent the 412-public-campaign email just now. Buggers.

Analogy of Cookie Jar and Football Game

The Cookie Jar Analogy
When children are caught stealing from the cookie jar, the first thing they do is drop the cookie. That's where we're at right now (almost). As good parents, we must offer a stern lecture. Then we need to put the cookie jar on a higher shelf where the children can't reach it, followed by a bit of discipline.

No cookie after dinner, either. Send them straight to their room to read the Constitution. Twice for good measure. While they're at it, maybe we should ask for a book reporte or spring a pop quiz.

We don't care that they put the cookie back; we're worried that they thought they could get away with it in the first place. It's a matter of trust. It can't go back to the way it was, because we don't have any faith in them. They've lost our respect, a difficult thing to earn a second time.

The Football Analogy
We're in the first quarter. After receiving the opening kickoff (the pay raise), the CleanSweepers put together a long and determined drive toward the goal line. The Incumbents defense was confused and thought the scoreboard (the media) wasn't working properly. Oddly, the refs (the Supremes) are now playing for the Incumbents.

We introduced the forward pass (the internet). They were left flat- footed. We muscled into the end zone with the aid of their collapsing defense (the Day 118 repeal). The extra point (dismal polling) was good. CleanSweepers lead 7-0.

Time for an onside kick (Newman & Nigro). We'll get the ball right back and start another drive down the field. It's still the first quarter and we've come out of the box like Super Bowl champions. Let's keep it up.

Feel free to 'high five' each other, but this is no time for a victory dance. The game is far from over.

City Council tentatively OKs nonprofit groups' 3-year pledge

Can beggers do anything more than smile and bear it? Sadly, the council has put itself in the lower role of simple handout taker.

City Council tentatively OKs nonprofit groups' 3-year pledge A slim majority of Pittsburgh City Council members tentatively approved a pact with nonprofit groups yesterday, and several said they'd need more information before a final vote Monday.
At stake is at least $13.2 million in pledged contributions from universities, hospitals, foundations and other charities to the cash-poor city, including $4.6 million this year.